At first glance, he appears to be a safe, conventional choice. I'd braced myself for a relative unknown, because that's how Bond casting has always worked, and an A-lister in the role is unprecedented. But the more I think about it, the more I think he's ideal.
Why it's more daring than it looks
For a start, he's a genuinely great actor. He's also already an A-lister, and no incoming Bond has ever arrived like that. Look at where each of them was when they got the call:
Sean Connery was a former milkman, lifeguard and Mr Universe entrant who had worked his way up through stage chorus lines and small film and TV parts, including Disney's Darby O'Gill and the Little People, before Dr. No in 1962. George Lazenby was an Australian car salesman turned model, best known for a chocolate advert, with no film acting experience at all when he made On Her Majesty's Secret Service in 1969.
Roger Moore came closest to being famous, thanks to TV's The Saint and The Persuaders!, but he was a small-screen star rather than a film one when Live and Let Die came along in 1973. Timothy Dalton was a respected Royal Shakespeare Company actor, with The Lion in Winter and Flash Gordon behind him, but hardly a household name before The Living Daylights in 1987. Pierce Brosnan was known mainly for the American TV detective series Remington Steele, with only modest film roles, before GoldenEye in 1995.
And Daniel Craig, admired for Our Friends in the North and Layer Cake, was so little known when Casino Royale was announced that some tabloids dubbed him "James Blonde".
Pattinson, by contrast, arrives with Twilight, Tenet and The Batman already behind him. That makes this choice daring in its own way. He isn't being made by Bond. He's bringing something with him.
What interests me most is that he's never really played a Bond-like role. Tenet and The Batman come closest, and both show he can carry a big, brooding, high-stakes film. I think he'll be very good at the darkness that's always been part of the character, especially Fleming's version of it.
What people forget is that he's also very funny when he's allowed to be. The Lighthouse is my favourite of his films, and it goes to some very funny (and very strange) places. A Bond who can do the darkness and land a dry one-liner is exactly what we want.
And for the record: he's not really my type, but I can see why plenty of people will be very happy to watch him in a dinner jacket. I certainly wouldn't turn down a martini with him. 🍸
Apparently, he needs to hit the gym
Within hours of the announcement, the comments were full of the same advice. "Get him on the protein shakes." "Where are the abs?"
Can I point everyone back to Fleming?
Fleming's Bond doesn't need a gym. His fitness has a job to do. He trains when the mission calls for it, and when he trains, he means it.
📖 Dr No: Before Crab Key, he and Quarrel set up a training routine. He swims, runs a mile, sunbathes, has a massage and is in bed by nine. It's a proper training camp on a beach, not a vanity project. Sound familiar? 🏃♂️🌴
📖 From Russia, with Love: He wakes up restless and drops straight into twenty slow press-ups. Then it's leg lifts until his stomach muscles scream, followed by toe touches, deep breathing and a hot-and-cold shower. That's discipline, and it's all done before breakfast.
📖 On Her Majesty's Secret Service: At Piz Gloria he hears a scream and does a quarter of an hour of knee-bends and press-ups, because he knows he'll need every muscle to get out.
📖 Thunderball: He's sent to a health farm, and to his own surprise he comes out feeling better than he ever has.
Fleming's Bond is lean, scarred and capable. His body is a tool for surviving, not something to show off. If we treat a sculpted six-pack as a requirement for the role, that tells us more about how we police men's bodies now than it does about Bond.
So let's give the man a chance. Judge Pattinson on how well he plays Bond, not on his muscle definition.